About Choice Surrogacy, Inc.
Choice Surrogacy, Inc. located in the hill country near Austin, Texas. Parents and surrogates choose Choice For Its trustworthy outstanding commitment To personalized professional guidance throughout your experience. We simplify your journey by eliminating waitlists and upfront fees. We only connect parents with surrogates after medical records are approved by your IVF Doctor. Choice has a 97.5% success rate on first time embryo transfers and a remarkable 99% match rate for parents selecting their ideal surrogate on the first profile presentation. Our high-touch agency is family owned and operated business comprised of experienced professionals within the surrogacy industry since 1993, providing 30 years of care for surrogates and parents worldwide.
Why Choose Choice Surrogacy Over Other Surrogate Agencies?
We are a niche agency that love what we do and do what we love on a very personal basis. We provide one on one guidance unlike the larger agencies. We choose to be small and keep the heart in surrogacy. This is a human experience not a business experience with Choice.
Choice Surrogacy is family owned and operated. A professional Mother Daughter team. We are not owned by a foreign entity nor a doctor’s consortium nor several absentee business partners. Only one owner who was a surrogate herself 22 years ago, and an industry professional for 30 years.
Choice Surrogacy's owner is a licensed and bonded surplus lines insurance broker in California and in Texas. She worked 20 years as a Lloyd’s of London Coverholder in the U.S. and the first Licensed Insurance Broker with authority to create most every insurance policy in the Assisted Reproduction Insurance arena over the last 30 years.
Choice Surrogacy provides excellent care and service while providing the lowest cost guaranteed programs in the surrogacy professional community together with providing the best benefits to your surrogate.
Choice is the only surrogacy agency offering agency insured Guaranteed Programs, stopping the loss of parent’s financials through the surrogacy journey.
We provide our surrogates with a base compensation of $58,000+ with other benefits and Guarantee we pay the most to surrogates by matching any other agencies surrogate pay.
![Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fsurrogacynetwork.org%2Fbiz%2Fchoice-surrogacy-inc%2F"e=Choice+Surrogacy%2C+Inc.&description=Choice+Surrogacy%2C+Inc.+located+in+the+hill+country+near+Austin%2C+Texas.+Parents+and+surrogates+choose+Choice+For+Its+trustworthy+outstanding+commitment+To+personalized+professional+guidance+throughout+your+experience.+We+simplify+your+journey+by+eliminating+waitlists+and+upfront+fees.+We+only+connect+parents+with+surrogates+after+medical+records+are+approved+by+your+IVF+Doctor.+Choice+has+a+97.5%25+success+rate+on+first+time+embryo+transfers+and+a+remarkable+99%25+match+rate+for+parents+selecting+their+ideal+surrogate+on+the+first+profile+presentation.+Our+high-touch+agency+is+family+owned+and+operated+business+comprised+of+experienced+professionals+within+the+surrogacy+industry+since+1993%2C+providing+30+years+of+care+for+surrogates+and+parents+worldwide.Why+Choose+Choice+Surrogacy+Over+Other+Surrogate+Agencies%3FWe+are+a+niche+agency+that+love+what+we+do+and+do+what+we+love+on+a+very+personal+basis.+We+provide+one+on+one+guidance+unlike+the+larger+agencies.+We+choose+to+be+small+and+keep+the+heart+in+surrogacy.+This+is+a+human+experience+not+a+business+experience+with+Choice.Choice+Surrogacy+is+family+owned+and+operated.+A+professional+Mother+Daughter+team.+We+are+not+owned+by+a+foreign+entity+nor+a+doctor%E2%80%99s+consortium+nor+several+absentee+business+partners.+Only+one+owner+who+was+a+surrogate+herself+22+years+ago%2C+and+an+industry+professional+for+30+years.Choice+Surrogacy%27s+owner+is+a+licensed+and+bonded+surplus+lines+insurance+broker+in+California+and+in+Texas.+She+worked+20+years+as+a+Lloyd%E2%80%99s+of+London+Coverholder+in+the+U.S.+and+the+first+Licensed+Insurance+Broker+with+authority+to+create+most+every+insurance+policy+in+the+Assisted+Reproduction+Insurance+arena+over+the+last+30+years.Choice+Surrogacy+provides+excellent+care+and+service+while+providing+the+lowest+cost+guaranteed+programs+in+the+surrogacy+professional+community+together+with+providing+the+best+benefits+to+your+surrogate.Choice+is+the+only+surrogacy+agency+offering+agency+insured+Guaranteed+Programs%2C+stopping+the+loss+of+parent%E2%80%99s+financials+through+the+surrogacy+journey.We+provide+our+surrogates+with+a+base+compensation+of+%2458%2C000%2B+with+other+benefits+and+Guarantee+we+pay+the+most+to+surrogates+by+matching+any+other+agencies+surrogate+pay.&picture=https%3A%2F%2Fsurrogacynetwork.org%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2FChoice-Surrogacy-Logo.png){kind=link}
Kim Phan
December 4, 2025 at 11:35 pmI do NOT recommend Choice Surrogacy to any intended parents considering using them. My experience as a hopeful surrogate (gestational carrier) started off like all the other positive reviewers. Trish is a skilled saleswoman, bragging about how her agency is simply the best so I did not even consider any others.
I expediently completed their questionnaires, interview, psych evaluation, health information requests plus other various hoops they hurried me to get through. They told me I cleared my medical records screening and that they found a match for me. This was earlier this spring. Their contract states monthly payments of $500 begin once medical records are cleared and there is a match. Except that did not happen, because then they later told me that the clinic decided against moving forward. Okay? I was confused but trusted them. A couple of months later, Choice said they found another clinic that approved my records (CCRM the Memorial location in Houston). They set me up on a match meeting with another couple and I accepted. Chloe emailed me stating I would finally start receiving my monthly payments. CCRM instructed me to begin taking birth control they sent to my pharmacy. Then later Choice told me CCRM changed their minds, because they now wanted confirmation that I did not have adenomyosis first (when I did not). The couple I matched with was crushed. I still expected to receive my monthly payments, because the misshap on their end was not my fault and I did my part according to the contract. But I still had both a transvaginal ultrasound AND a vaginal MRI done anyway at my own expense to confirm I did not have adenomyosis (and of course I did not have it). I then asked Choice if I could be reimbursed for the co-payment. They ignored the question. I asked about the status of the couple that I had met and matched with. They ignored that question too. I asked about next steps with CCRM or other clinics. They read the question in the chat and again simply chose not to respond a word. They flat out ghosted me after that for months, until I terminated our agreement. I requested my file from them and of course they won’t provide it. It has been weeks since then, so this review is long overdue and they definitely had it coming.
I truly wasted so many critical months with this agency, and also went on birth control because of CCRM for zero reason. If you are intended parents considering spending thousands of your hard earned dollars in the 5-digits on either of them, I would seriously reconsider. I intend to speak about my experience soon on social media since my comments about them keeps getting deleted in Facebook groups (I’m pretty sure they bribed them to remove them or they are secretly the admins). Trish is a master gaslighter who will try to spin this another way and deflect blame, but I have kept screenshots of everything and happy to share it.
Feel free to email me if you want more details. I will be leaving a Google review soon and my email address will be in the username. Look out for it in the upcoming days.
Trish Taylor
January 4, 2026 at 8:08 amI’m saddened that your experience with us caused you frustration and disappointment. That is never the intended outcome. Surrogacy is deeply personal, and when medical decisions change unexpectedly, it can feel incredibly unfair.
Because IVF clinics only determine medical eligibility, we at Choice Surrogacy do not approve medical records, and those determinations can evolve, agencies like ours don’t control whether a match can proceed. When a clinic declines to move forward, intended parents have no ability to continue, regardless of everyone’s best intentions.
Despite two separate medical declinations, Choice Surrogacy elected, in good faith, to issue a $500 payment on 08/28/2025 following an in-depth phone conversation. This amount exceeded any documented out-of-pocket expenses. The discussion was conducted respectfully and with only kindness and well wishes expressed.
While I won’t discuss individual details in a public forum, we stand by our strong commitment to ethical practices, and strict adherence to physician guidance. I am always willing to speak directly to resolve concerns and bring clarity where possible.
I wish you well,
Trish Taylor
Founder, Choice Surrogacy
K W
April 12, 2025 at 9:20 amI’m a first-time gestational surrogate, and I submitted my application to Choice Surrogacy about a month ago. I just matched with the MOST incredible intended parents, and I honestly couldn’t be more excited!
From the very beginning, Trish and Chloe have been absolutely amazing—so warm, supportive, and incredibly responsive. I can text them anytime and always get a quick, helpful response, which has made such a difference as someone new to this process. I’ve felt informed, respected, and truly cared for every step of the way.
I’m especially impressed with Trish’s extensive knowledge and expertise—she clearly knows this process inside and out. Having someone with that level of experience in your corner brings so much peace of mind.
This experience has been incredible so far, and I’m so grateful I chose Choice. Whether you’re considering surrogacy as a surrogate or as intended parents, I can’t recommend this agency enough. 10/10 all around!
Trish Taylor
April 18, 2025 at 8:48 amYour match was pure kismet! And your intended parents are over the moon about you being the special one to help them create their dreams of family. I knew I wanted to work with you the first 15 min of meeting you! Chloe and I are so excited to guide your through one of the most special times in your life. Thank you very much for your kind words about our company and our long time commitment to having all our people feel comfortable, secure and cared for from the very beginning of our journey together creating a healthy happy surrogacy journey. Here we go!!!
All my best,
Trish Taylor
Mani Elizabeth
March 22, 2025 at 1:15 amAt first glance, from the website, it seems like this is an ethical agency. However, during my call with them, the owner Trish hard-sold me her program. She picked up on words that I was using and repeated them back to me to convince me that the program was the best choice. She asked about other agencies I was checking out and gave me tons of reasons why they weren’t good choices. Then, she insisted that I use the reproductive attorney that she would choose for me, instead of the attorney that I was already working with. After I expressed some discomfort to that, she said that it’s important to use only the best of the best attorneys in the business and implied that the attorney I was working with wasn’t as good as hers (which just isn’t true though). After the initial consultation, she told me she would follow up with more information about the program, send across referrals, etc. but I never heard from her again. It was a very icky consultation with a lot of red flags, and left me feeling disappointed and disheartened.
Trish Taylor
March 25, 2025 at 1:42 amHello Mani Elizabeth,
I’m truly sorry to hear that you left our consultation feeling disheartened. It’s never my intention for anyone to feel pressured or uncomfortable, and I apologize that my approach came across that way. We have so many folks to help and much education and information to share. I see my role in the surrogacy process as providing expert guidance—drawing on over 30 years of experience and a deep passion for helping intended parents and surrogates navigate this complex journey with as much legal and financial protection as possible.
I’d like to clarify that the name provided in your review does not reflect a consultation with me at Choice Surrogacy. However I did have a conversation with one couple, the only one I can remember having issues with our attorney referral we give, that were adamant about using their own personal family attorney with no experience in surrogacy and I mentioned I would ask (or they could ask) our recommended attorney to allow the family attorney to review the Gestational Carrier Agreement. I also may have spent more than an hour and half being with you as you shared you have had some negative experiences with other agencies and I wanted to be sure I listened to you and intentfully helped by comparing the differences in other agencies vs Choice you brought to me.
We only use one firm that has been the creator of much original surrogacy law for our country. I too have worked with California Legislature to pass a Family Code law in California. Bill AB 2344 the first law ever to connect liability of insurance regarding both parents and surrogate to the surrogacy agreement. The attorneys we work with also insert all our one-of-a-kind financial programs within the GCA, therefore, encompassing the detailed proprietary plan, it is not a typical escrow or GCA. Choice is unique in the industry and to compare against others is often misunderstood in standard contracts. Our attorney referrals also act for our international clients as a claim’s negotiator, free of charge, for their newborn here in the states with no insurance coverages. During this time in our country’s state of the government where the laws of surrogacy could be unknown in the near future, we must have keen attorneys on our side, meaning the surrogate side and the parent side in order to circumvent any unexpected changes in the law that may come our way. Of course, there are no fees shared between us and any attorneys as that is completely not legal. I do not understand the use of the red flag comment.
We also gave no referrals to you as you never responded, yes, you would enjoy working with us. We only refer once we have a verbal or written agreement of the parents desire to work with us.
There are many opinions about surrogacy practices, and it’s common for longstanding agencies to refer their clients to specific attorneys based on trusted relationships and past successes for their clients and surrogates. Some agencies are even owned by the surrogacy attorney or have partners that are surrogacy attorneys. At Choice, we work very intimately with intended parents for an average of 12-15 months, guiding each case with care and expert insight to ensure a predictable and well-protected process.
Considering the depth and duration of support we offer, I respectfully ask that you review your impression based on a single phone call. Negative reviews of this nature can have a significant impact on a business and on my ability to help others in the future. I truly care about the journeys of the families, both parents and surrogates I work with and hope you might reconsider your feedback.
Sincerely,
Trish
Andreana Hesson
December 18, 2024 at 9:48 amFrom the very beginning to the end, my experience with Choice Surrogacy was nothing short of extraordinary. I cannot fully express how supported I felt throughout this magical journey—it’s truly something you can only understand once you’ve gone through it yourself.
Trish, Chloe, and my incredible Intended Parents (IPs) were by my side every step of the way. I was so fortunate to be matched with the most amazing IPs, and I always joke with Trish that she’s truly found her calling in pairing surrogates with their perfect matches. She has a gift for it!
The support I received was unparalleled. Choice Surrogacy not only made me feel valued but also created a safe space for open communication, even during the more challenging conversations. They listened to me, supported me, and ensured that I always felt at ease.
My experience was everything I could have hoped for and more—an ideal journey that I wish all surrogates could have. I can’t say enough good things about Choice Surrogacy and the wonderful team behind it. This was a perfect experience, and I’m beyond grateful to have been part of it.
Megan Jones
September 13, 2024 at 6:52 amI had the incredible opportunity to be a surrogate through Choice Surrogacy, and it was truly a life-changing experience. Trish and Chloe were both super attentive, supportive, and professional every step of the way. They made me feel valued and comfortable, providing excellent guidance and compassionate care throughout the entire process. Thanks to their dedication and expertise, I felt confident and well-supported. Great communication throughout and follow up even after my journey ended! Choice Surrogacy has truly made a positive impact on my life, and I highly recommend their services to anyone considering surrogacy.
Danielle Cortes
July 31, 2024 at 10:29 amWorking with Choice Surrogacy was the BEST experience for my second time as a surrogate. They guaranteed top compensation—and actually exceeded my expectations by not only matching their competitors but BESTING it—without any hassles. The insurance coverage was comprehensive, giving me complete peace of mind. Their expert guidance through the IVF process made me feel secure and supported every step of the way. The concierge-level attention for travel and appointments was over the top; I never had to worry about a thing. Trish and Chloe are amazing, and I highly recommend them to anyone considering surrogacy! You won’t be disappointed.
Julie Ford
July 20, 2024 at 3:49 pmI have had a wonderful experience with Choice. I am on my second surrogacy journey, but even on my first they made the process so fun and straightforward. They are available as much as possible for both their surrogates and intended parents. They are on top of all appointments, hospital visits, and even stay with you after labor to make sure you are healing okay. They are amazing!
Lindsey Smith
July 8, 2024 at 6:53 amMy experience as a surrogate was nothing short of absolutely amazing with Choice Surrogacy. Trish and Chloe were there every step of the way, booking my travel and Ubers, helping me with what to expect from fertility clinics and doctors appointments. They truly treated me like a top priority, even though I know I was not the only one. The only thing I had to worry about at the end of the day was growing and delivering a baby for a beautiful couple. I am so thankful that my first experience as a surrogate was with Choice, Trish and Chloe!
Victoria Rosenquist
June 21, 2024 at 9:33 pmI had an incredibly positive experience with Choice Surrogacy. From start to finish, the process was so easy and seamless. The team genuinely cared about me as a person, ensuring that I felt supported and valued every step of the way.
During my journey, I faced a difficult delivery, and the Choice Surrogacy team went above and beyond by showing up in person to check on me. Their presence and support during that challenging time meant the world to me.
One of the most remarkable aspects of my experience was the introduction to my intended parents. They have become some of my closest friends, and I cherish the bond we’ve formed.
Overall, I highly recommend Choice Surrogacy for their exceptional care, compassion, and dedication. They truly make the surrogacy experience remarkable and meaningful.
Taylor Huffman
June 20, 2024 at 12:59 pmI’d like to share my experience as a first-time surrogate with Choice Surrogacy. From the beginning, they ensured I received top compensation for my first pregnancy without any hassle. Their thorough insurance coverage and expert IVF guidance answered all my questions, making me feel confident and supported right from the very beginning. I love being pregnant, so when I found out I could earn good money quickly while helping a deserving family have a baby, I knew it was the right choice. The meticulous attention to detail, even down to travel and appointments, made me feel special, and I didn’t have to worry about a thing. Trish and Chloe are incredible. You won’t regret working with them!
Sara Millan
June 18, 2024 at 3:49 pmI recently finished up my journey with Choice Surrogacy, and had nothing but a great experience with them. Trish and Chloe were able to help me find what I would call a perfect match. They made the process of all the appointments, transfer, and delivery as easy as possible. They were even able to make it to my transfer and delivery! My experience was completely stress-free. I never had to worry about what to do or what to expect and I knew I could reach out any time of day if needed. I was lucky enough to find life long friends through this process and also help a family be whole. I’m glad I picked Choice Surrogacy for my first time as a surrogate!
Elizabeth Resendez
June 18, 2024 at 3:38 pmMy experience with Choice Surrogacy was amazing! Trish and Chloe are very kind . Choice surrogacy made it stress free. As a first-time surrogate,They made sure I received top compensation . They guided me through all the IVF steps. They made me feel very confident. I can’t wait to work with them again. I highly recommend them to anyone considering surrogacy! You won’t be disappointed.❤️❤️
OPJ KJDR
May 27, 2024 at 2:42 amToday, we are overjoyed to hold our beautiful baby boy in our arms. We are full of gratitude for Choice Surrogacy’s role in bringing this incredible joy into our lives. We wholeheartedly recommend Choice Surrogacy to anyone considering surrogacy as their path to parenthood. Thank you for making our dreams come true!
From our first interaction, the agency’s professionalism and genuine care stood out. They guided us through every step of the surrogacy process with clarity and compassion, ensuring we felt supported and informed. The surrogate we were matched with was nothing short of amazing. Her dedication, kindness, and resilience during the entire journey left us in awe. The agency’s meticulous selection and matching process ensured that we were paired with someone who shared our values and commitment. The medical care, legal support, and emotional encouragement provided by Choice Surrogacy were exemplary. Choice was also able to help us navigate the additional risks we faced as international intended parents and provide us a clear roadmap through this complicated personal, emotional and legal process.
Kaitlan Fair
April 23, 2024 at 8:32 amWow, after starting with choice surrogacy back in 2018 to now being on my 3rd journey with them I have nothing but love and respect for this company! I was so nervous starting out as a first time GC but they made sure every step of the way I had so much support. They are the company that answers your questions before you ask. They have always been one step ahead of me and I never had to wonder what’s next. My matching process has been incredible every step! From lawyers to the amazing doctors I have had the pleasure of working with, they always made sure to stay in contact and also helped with all appointments being made! If I ever have questions and need that extra support they are there! Choice surrogacy truly makes you feel like family and they have never pushed me out of my comfort zone, they really show you what this amazing world of surrogacy is. I will be forever grateful to them in the support they give!