Top 5 Most Reviewed Surrogacy Agencies

Choosing the right surrogacy agency is one of the most important decisions intended parents and surrogates will make on their fertility journey. With so many options available, it can feel overwhelming to know where to start or which agencies truly deliver on their promises of support, professionalism, and success.

That's where real experiences matter most. SurrogacyNetwork.org serves as a trusted platform for finding and reviewing top surrogacy agencies, with over 350 agencies listed. Based on real feedback from those who have used their services, we've identified the 5 agencies that have earned the most reviews.

1. Choice Surrogacy

Choice Surrogacy (14 reviews) receives positive feedback from surrogates and intended parents. Reviewers frequently highlight exceptional support and responsiveness from owner Trish and program manager Chloe, noting their availability and dedication throughout the journey. Many surrogates mention seamless matching processes, top compensation, full travel coordination, and feeling genuinely cared for. 

First-time and repeat surrogates alike express appreciation for clear guidance through IVF, appointments, and delivery. Several intended parents praise the agency’s professionalism, compassionate communication, and thoughtful surrogate matching. International clients also note Choice’s help navigating legal and logistical complexities. The agency is described as organized, ethical, and deeply committed to creating a smooth, stress-free experience.

2. The Genesis Group

The Genesis Group (14 reviews) receives consistently positive reviews from both surrogates and intended parents. Many describe the team as warm, ethical, and genuinely caring, with support that feels personal rather than business like. Reviewers often say they felt well informed and never left in the dark, with staff who were responsive, organized, and proactive at every step. Coordinators and case managers such as Erica, Kelly, Jennifer, Kimberly, Heidi, and Lisa are frequently praised for their kindness, knowledge, and steady communication.

Several reviews also emphasize thoughtful matching, with intended parents and surrogates saying Genesis prioritized alignment in values, expectations, and personalities. Repeat surrogates note feeling protected, respected, and valued, and some mention the agency handling major administrative burdens so everyone could focus on the journey itself. A few reviewers also point to support continuing after delivery, including help with post birth logistics and staying connected over time.

3. Egg Donor & Surrogate Solutions

Egg Donor & Surrogate Solutions (14 reviews) receives positive reviews from surrogates. Many describe feeling well-supported, appreciated, and informed throughout their journeys. Coordinators like Whitney, Lauren, and Meg are frequently praised for being responsive, organized, and caring. Several reviewers highlight smooth matching with intended parents, timely communication, and detailed guidance through each step of the process. 

First-time and repeat surrogates note that the agency made them feel like individuals, not just numbers, and helped create a sense of community through surrogate support groups. Some mention thoughtful gestures like gifts and regular check-ins. The agency is also noted for clear expectations, strong advocacy, and fostering mutual respect between surrogates and intended parents.

4. SurrogateFirst

Reviews for SurrogateFirst (13 reviews) describe a mix of experiences from both surrogates and intended parents. Many surrogates report positive journeys, highlighting strong support, clear communication, thoughtful gestures, and successful matches. Some mention forming lasting bonds with staff and fellow surrogates. A few surrogates shared that they felt under-supported during parts of the process, especially around communication with case managers or after unsuccessful transfers.

Intended parents also report mixed experiences: while some describe smooth coordination and excellent matches, others note limited communication, unmet expectations, or feeling secondary to the surrogate. Despite challenges, several reviewers express gratitude for the outcome and plan to return for future journeys.

5. Brownstone Surrogacy

Reviews for Brownstone Surrogacy (8 reviews) describe highly positive experiences from surrogates. Many mention strong communication, personalized support, and feeling valued rather than treated like a number. Founder Jarret and Director of Surrogate Services Yesenia are frequently named for their responsiveness, care, and attentiveness throughout the journey. Surrogates appreciated having travel, appointments, and logistics handled smoothly, along with thoughtful gifts and regular check-ins.

Several reviewers noted successful matches with intended parents and a sense of community and friendship with the agency. Even first-time surrogates felt well-informed and supported. Brownstone’s smaller size and personal involvement were seen as key strengths, with some reviewers highlighting that both founders have personal experience with surrogacy.

Explore more agencies and read verified reviews in our surrogacy agency directory to find the right match for your journey.